We just won a case in Federal Court quashing a permit issued to an exploration company that was operating on First Nations land without their consent. The decision, attached here, is a great win for the Yellowknives Dene and Lutsel Ke’e First Nations. The judge found that the company “did not act in accordance with the Board’s guidelines on consultation. There were no face-to-face meetings with chiefs on issues; no real meetings with the communities and no attempt to address any of the communities’ or leaders’ ideas into [the company’s] proposal. [The company] simply refused to negotiate. INAC did nothing more than accept [the company’s] assurances and advise the Board that consultation had occurred. There was no independent inquiry by either body much less an “opportunity to be heard” for the Applicants. These actions (or lack thereof) were contrary to the Board’s obligations and to the principles of fairness. Therefore, the Permit cannot stand.” OKT associates Matt McPherson and Judith Rae were invaluable co-pilots on this case. Congratulations to all!
By Kate Kempton
Related Posts
Practicing Law North of 60: The Path of a Northern Lawyer
I’ve lived and practiced law across Northern Canada for nearly a decade. When I started this journey, it was just me, quite literally.
My arrival in the North began in…
Read More...
OKT Tops Best Lawyers Rankings
OKT thanks our peers for recognizing our lawyers as national leaders in the new Best Lawyers in Canada directory. Congratulations to Larry Innes, Nancy Kleer, Lorraine Land,
Opportunity for renewing treaty federalism, recognizing Canada’s legal pluralism, part two
Courts have ruled that Indian Act governments are subject to the Charter; however, they operate under delegated authority. The exercise of inherent power is distinct. Neither the Crown nor any of…
Read More...